Street Racing Laws Ruled Unconstitutional… Again!

For the second time, Ontario’s new anti-street racing laws have been deemed unconstitutional.  This time Justice Peter Wright, has thrown out charges by indicating the unconstitutionality of the new law.

Justice Peter West, a provincial court judge in Newmarket, found that an accused driver’s Charter rights are “clearly infringed” by the potential jail time because the law doesn’t permit the person to put forward a defence.

“There is no air of reality to the Crown’s submissions that a defendant charged with stunt driving under section 172 of the Highway Traffic Act … has an available defence of due diligence,” West stated in a written ruling.

“The possibility of the imposition of up to six months imprisonment thereby renders this section unconstitutional.”

I can see this going up the judicial ladder.  We shall keep our pedal off the metal, until this is decided.  It is however, reported that police agencies still plan on enforcing the law.

Full story here

About the Author

Ryan Venables
Ryan Venables is a third year law student at the University of Western Ontario. He holds B.A. (2001) from the University of Western Ontario in Political Science and Sociology. Ryan was also enrolled in a M.A.- Journalism at the University of Western Ontario before withdrawing to attend law school. Before pursuing a formal education in law, Ryan served with the York Regional Police as a police officer for five years specializing in organized crime. He also served in the Special Investigations Section with the Royal Canadian Mounted Police for two years. His legal interests include employment/labour, criminal, family, and human rights law. When Ryan is done law school he will be articling with Ross & McBride LLP in Hamilton, Ontario.